Learning outcomeExplain what a dispute resolution clause does and choose the right method for a contract.
A dispute resolution clause decides, before any dispute exists, how a dispute will be resolved.
It is often the last clause in a contract and the least negotiated, yet it is the clause the parties turn to when everything else has failed.
The clause is drafted when relations are good; it is used when they are not.
Four questions every clause must answer
1Which method?Negotiation, mediation, arbitration, expert determination or court litigation, or a combination.
2Which rules?Institutional rules, ad hoc rules, or the court’s rules of procedure.
3Where?The seat (legal home) of an arbitration, or the courts with jurisdiction.
4Who decides, and how many?The number and appointment of arbitrators or the mediator.
Why it mattersWhen a clause is silent or unclear, the parties fight about the process before they can fight about the merits. That costs time and money, and it can make an award hard to enforce.
Choosing the method
| Method |
Outcome |
Binding? |
Best for |
| Negotiation |
Agreement between the parties |
Only if signed as a settlement |
Ongoing relationships, early disputes |
| Mediation |
Settlement helped by a neutral mediator |
Only if the parties sign a settlement agreement |
Preserving relationships; confidential, fast outcomes |
| Arbitration |
Award by a private tribunal |
Yes, final and enforceable |
Cross-border contracts, technical disputes, confidentiality |
| Expert determination |
Decision by an expert |
As agreed in the contract |
Narrow technical or valuation issues |
| Litigation |
Court judgment |
Yes, subject to appeal |
Urgent public remedies, multiple non-consenting parties |
The law in NigeriaThe Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 (AMA 2023) now governs both arbitration and mediation. It repealed the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, Cap. A18, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria 2004, and introduced modern tools such as emergency arbitrators, third-party funding rules and an optional Award Review Tribunal.
Key points
- The clause is drafted when relations are good; it is used when they are not.
- Arbitration gives a binding, enforceable result; mediation and negotiation need a signed settlement.
- Most commercial contracts benefit from a combination: talk first, then mediate, then arbitrate.