Module 1: What mediation is, and how it differs from arbitration and litigation

Learning outcomeExplain what mediation is, how it differs from arbitration and litigation, and when it is the right choice.

Mediation is a voluntary, confidential process in which a neutral third person, the mediator, helps the parties to a dispute talk, understand each other and reach their own agreement.

The mediator does not decide who is right. The mediator has no power to impose a solution. The decision stays with the parties. That single feature is what makes mediation different from almost every other way of resolving a dispute.

In court and in arbitration, someone decides for you. In mediation, you decide together.

Four features of mediation

1VoluntaryThe parties choose to mediate, and either party can usually walk away. No one is forced to settle.
2ConfidentialWhat is said in mediation is generally kept private and cannot be used against a party later.
3Neutral helpThe mediator is impartial. The mediator manages the process, not the outcome.
4Party controlThe parties design their own solution, which can include things a court could never order, such as an apology or a new business arrangement.

Positions and interests

A position is what a party says it wants: “Pay me ₦5 million now.” An interest is why the party wants it: cash flow, recognition, fairness, a relationship it wants to protect, or simply to be heard.

Litigation and arbitration deal mainly with positions and legal rights. Mediation works on interests. When parties understand each other’s interests, options appear that neither side saw at the start. This is the heart of mediation, and you will practise it throughout this course.

ExampleA landlord demands that a tenant pay arrears or leave. The tenant wants to stay. In mediation it emerges that the landlord needs regular cash flow to repay a loan, and the tenant is owed money by a customer next month. A payment plan with a small deposit now meets both interests, and the landlord keeps a good tenant.

Mediation compared

Negotiation Mediation Arbitration Litigation
Who decides? The parties The parties, helped by a mediator The arbitral tribunal The judge
Binding? Only if a settlement is signed Only if a settlement agreement is signed Yes, the award is final and enforceable Yes, subject to appeal
Private? Yes Yes, confidential Usually private Public hearings
Relationship Can be preserved Often preserved or repaired Adversarial Adversarial
Cost and time Lowest Low; often days or weeks Moderate to high Often high and slow

When mediation works best, and when it does not

Mediation is a strong choice when the parties have a relationship worth keeping (business partners, employer and employee, family, neighbours, landlord and tenant), when the dispute is about money or arrangements that can be negotiated, when speed and privacy matter, and when both sides are able to make a decision.

Mediation may not be suitable when a party needs an urgent court order, when one side wants a public ruling or a legal precedent, when there is a serious safety risk or violence, or when a party lacks the capacity or authority to settle and cannot be properly supported or represented.

The law in NigeriaThe Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 (AMA 2023) gives mediation a statutory framework for the first time. Part II of the Act (sections 67 to 87) covers mediation of domestic and international disputes. A settlement agreement reached in mediation can be enforced as a contract, a consent judgment or a consent award, and the Act applies the Singapore Convention on Mediation to international settlement agreements. Courts and multi-door courthouses across Nigeria also refer suitable cases to mediation.

Who can be a mediator?

Good mediators come from many backgrounds: law, human resources, business, the public service, religious and traditional leadership, social work and teaching. Legal knowledge helps, but it is not the core skill. The core skills are listening, asking good questions, staying neutral, managing emotions and helping people think clearly about options. This course builds those skills step by step.

Key points

  • Mediation is voluntary, confidential and neutral, and the parties keep control of the outcome.
  • Mediators work with interests (the “why”), not only positions (the “what”).
  • A mediated settlement becomes binding only when the parties sign a settlement agreement.
  • In Nigeria, the AMA 2023 now governs mediation and the enforcement of settlement agreements.

Contact Support

LOGIN

Welcome! Log into your account